In March 2009, Liv-ex recreated the 1855 Classification by ranking major Left Banks using the original 1855 criterion: price. The results of our analysis caused quite a stir and can be viewed in full here. Now, two years on, the market has shifted and we have updated our classification to reflect current trading conditions.
Criteria and calculation:
To qualify for the Liv-ex Bordeaux Classification, wines had to be from the Left Bank (including Pessac-Leognan) and be produced in quantities of more than 2,000 cases. Only the first wine of each estate was considered. We then calculated the average case price for every qualifying wine (lowest available wholesale price for an in-bond owc 12x75cl case in good condition, excluding duty and sales tax) for the past five vintages, 2005-2009. Prices are as of 30 April 2011.
As the brokers did in 1855 (and we did previously in 2009) we then split up the wines according to price band, which for 2011 are as follows:
- 1st Growths: £3,300 a case and above
- 2nd Growths: £700 to £3,299
- 3rd Growths: £400 to £699
- 4th Growths: £280 to £399
- 5th Growths: £220 to £279
These price bands were modified from those used in 2009 by calculating the average price difference between the 2009 and 2011 studies for each level of the classification and then applying this modifier to the previous price bands. This change ranged from 11% for the Fifths, to more than 60% for the Firsts.
It remains a matter of academic debate whether the wines were listed in their respective classes in order of price/quality – though the evidence seems to point to this being so. We have assumed they were for the purposes of this analysis.
Download The 2011 Liv-ex Bordeaux Classification
2011 highlights:
Lafite retakes its position as the top wine of the Left Bank this year - a position it surrendered to Latour in 2009. And in a repeat of the Liv-ex '09 Classification, Mission Haut Brion joins the ranks of the First Growths, although it has started to fall behind. Lower down the list, Duhart Milon, Beychevelle and Pontet Canet graduate to Second-Growth status. Leoville Barton drops down to become a Third Growth.
The second wines: If the second wines from the great estates were included, where would they rank?
If we include the second wines, which didn't exist in 1855, 13 would qualify for this year's classification. Most notable is the fact that Carruades would be counted amongst the First Growths. Meanwhile, Forts de Latour would be the top Second Growth, with Pavillon Rouge, Petit Mouton and Clarence Haut Brion also positioned within the ranks of the Seconds.
Comparing the most recent classification to that of 2009, the table below shows the biggest climbers. Many of these are brands that are popular in Asia.
Can anyone advise if that old Lafite (I believe, from the chateau's cellar, circa 1860-80) that sold a while back in Asia for around $US 233,000 per bottle has been consumed, and if so, how was it holding up?
Posted by: Michael Donohue | 27 May 2011 at 12:15 AM